Brian I'm not saying your wrong in your opinion. All I was stating was that the offer that Mike eventually rejected was the correct decision and that offer was better than the one that Troy gave. My point was Biggio is worthless to a team trying to rebuild. I think that's why Mike said the deal wasn't close using Troy's words. The other thing is I'd rather have a low rook 3 than Nady who has done basically nothing. Troy's a good owner as is everyone else in these leagues. but, if your rebuilding your better off with picks or solid prospects and niether deal accomplihed that.