I could see someone in contention and needing a couple of starters who could contribute immediately taking that trade

I can not imagine how good an offense a team would need to be in contention if those 2 guys would make your rotation. That being the case I can't see a scenario where this is a good offer (while people defended the offer I didn't see anyone say they would do the trade). However, whether it's bad enough to go to the bulletin board is another question.