Which one would you acquire to start at SS?

Player A: SLG = .466, OBP = .377, ODR = 2, Range = 2, FPCT = 2, DP = 2
Player B: SLG = .455, OBP = .333, ODR = 5.1, Range = 5.2, FPCT = 5, DP = 5

Or do you not bother getting either one and just use Player C who is already on the roster

Player C: SLG = .366, OBP = .323, ODR = 4, Range = 4, FPCT = 4, SP = 4