Tim a lot depends whether that team coontends or not so age maybe a favtor. Player A's offensive numbers are slighly better than B's and I agree with Ken in most cases I'd take 8. Unfortunately, because I took that approach with a lot of teams I lost a lot of games because of errors. I'd take B because of defense, but, I wouldn't give much as he's not a major upgrade over what you have. The funny thing is if you offered the player you have for B and offered a slight FA upgrade I have a feeling the owner on the other side might reject. I'd take B though to answer the question.