Are we talking Corey Patterson, who never sees a pitch he doesn't like?
Of course he might make the team this year with Don Baylor managing, but I think he will disappoint.
Still, he is young. I just don't think he merits being one of the top 5 with his strike zone judgment.
That said, here are my five:
Furcal
Burrell
Zito
Eaton
Fifth one is tough--Piatt if he's not too blocked
or Garland, if you are willing to wait a year

Don't mind me--I'm always contrary!
Dave