To be fair, I did accidently leave off Wes Helms(from AZ) and Scott Elarton(to AZ) off the evaluation portion of the trade. And while Elarton has a great deal of upside, I still don't pull this trade; I am unwilling to send All Stars in Clemens, Schilling, and Cirillo, solid players in Aurillia, Ligtenburg, and Mantei for essentially Tatis, Elarton, and Colon. Maybe I'm the idiot, I don't know. Other opinions are welcomed....