You state that you get Colon, in one part of your
message, Radke in another, and Elarton in a third.
If you were to get all three pitchers, as well
as Tatis, then you would be getting a good deal.

Please clarify exactly what the offer was. By the
way, your offer wasn't even close compared to his.

His offer wasn't bad if it included all three
pitchers that you mention.

I'd take Tatis over Cirillo, and a combo of
Elarton, Radke, and Colon over Clemens and
Schilling.

I agree also that you should E-mail back then owner
asking what his intentions were. Many first offers
are just a decent counter-offer away from being
a good deal.

Ken