I agree with Tim on this one.

Most likely, the away manager didn't submit any lineups and the robot is just displaying the SP that it would pick if usage was not a concern (highest grade starter with at least 30 BFA).

I blame the home manager for not bothering to open up the away manager's team page. I make this a habit before I start any home series.

While I play the home game, I have the away team's roster up in my browser, and mine in another browser window. That way, I can quickly view their splits, league stats, usage, etc and be a better manager that way. I've been burned one too many times in year's past and now it's just part of my normal home pre-game routine to check that the away starting pitcher is legit.

Jon, STL Trash