Depends... can you tell me exactly where the balls were hit? Seriously... I know this is a stat that is kept (Bill Mazeroski's books used to show them).

If a teams pitching staff is set up that most players end up pulling the ball to sharp right or left field, the CF will not be able to make those balls. That would damage his rating despite the fact he is actually ranging quite far into center-left and center-right.

I myself don't have those stats... but would like to see them.