I’m in a dilemma. I used an INN catcher as my left handed platoon for the whole year. He did a decent job as he had a good OBP. I thought that all INN players were eligible for the playoffs. (I was surprised I made the playoffs, now I’ve one my first series) I found out after the playoffs had started that he isn’t eligible for the playoffs due to the 50 PA rule. So he was removed from my roster. I see three possible choices.

1. I can have Karim Garcia be part of my catcher platoon, but he will be out of position.
2. I can pick up a INN catcher, but he will be terrible.
3. Have my exsting INN catcher be reinstated.

Let me know what everyone thinks should be done. Here is my opinion on each.
A new INN catcher pretty much douses any chances I have to win, as it would be like hitting two pitchers in a row.
Using my existing catcher would work, but doesn’t meet the rules.
Karim Garcia gives me the best possible hitting, but I lose some defensively. The problem is that I don’t lose enough defensively, in my opinion, because the game doesn’t punish out of position catchers enough. Please read the above topic for more clarification and my solotion.

Thanks guys.