To pull together a couple of the threads from below (non-catchers catching as Giles did in the playoffs in one league; and Defensive Ratings), I don't follow Giles in Real Time and haven't even seen him on tv that I can think of. Is he really as bad defensively as he's rated? I have him on one of my teams and with his ratings, he rarely gets to ANYTHING hit to him in the OF. I couldn't even think of playing him in CF.

Dave N