I'm a lunatic then, cause I think some of those really good defensive 3B and SS could hold their own behind the plate.

You know what though? We'll never know because it never happens in real life...so the whole conversation is pure speculation...with noone being wrong.

I guess my point is that you can't say that someone would suck behind the plate because there's not much to base that on....just like I can't prove that they'd be good...it's speculation both ways really.

Jon