I would reject. The managed team is getting FOUR players who will help immediately for two picks, a prospect (Overbay), an injry prone player (Mantei) and a journeyman (Stynes). Perhaps two of those players from the managerless team in exchange for the three players and two picks would seem fair to me.

PS I wanted to disclose that the commish has already rejected a trade I offered in another league of my #1 RK for K Rogers.