Casey,
I bet you can't start Redmond either but I bet you can start any righthander. What happens with neglected teams is that if the default lineup vs RH or LH is missing three or more players the robot will not let you play. When you select a righhander (which you did in the first four games) your opponents default lineup will have two or less players missing. You have two solutions: Start a righthander if you are anxious to play right away or email Mike Bravard and ask him to erase your opponents default lineup. The robot will then choose a lineup without any missing players and you can start Wolf. I have had this problem several times over the years and I suspect that is your current problem. Hope that helps!