Mike -

Thanks for responding and posting your opinion on Guillen. Yes, he's a servicable SS, but Neagle/Munro aren't chopped liver either:

Neagle 164IP, 5.8/4.0
Munro 80IP, 5.6/7.2, .654 ROPS

My rotation is in a serious bind right now. I just used up Benes' innings, Radke is almost done, Johnson is in the yellow, Simontacchi is at 113%, Mays is INN and an injury away from sitting out the rest of my regular season. The only reliable SP I have is Glavine. If Mays, Johnson and Simontacchi all get their injuries at the same time, I'm hosed.

IMO, getting Neagle and Munro and their 244 innings is far more valuable to me than Guillen (who is resting on the farm).

If that's not enough to get the deal done, I'll see if Tim can throw in another player or pick to even it up some more for you.

Thanks,
Jon