To me, the only real red flag is Pujols. I don't understand stripping a marquee young player like him from a managerless team.
Without him, you could discount PB value to a great degree because of most of the players' ages. I tried to get Pujols from a managerless team with a solid offer and was rebuffed. I just assumed it was out of a desire to keep a "NAME" player on the unowned team.
Dave N