I guess everyone has their own definition of what a superstar is.

At this point in their careers the only person listed above that seems to qualify is Pedro Martinez. Clemens is about done... Palmeiro is about done.

If I were drafting from scratch my draft ranking for the players that were mentioned in this thread would start with

Pedro Martinez
Edgar Renteria
Troy Glaus
Kevin Millwood

so in that context I think the managerless team did well.