Cabrera/Baldelli from 2003 spring reports top 50 rookies, I had tabulated 7 different publications. It ended with Baldelli at #10 on average, and with Cabrera at #37.

Who will end up better in the long run, maybe neither. They both may end up all-stars, or they both end up as has beens. Thats what makes these leagues exciting, we all have different opinions.