Defense matters.

Kotsay is an 8.7 range in CF with an 8 arm. He's not going to be on my farm team even if I just want him for late inning use to protect a lead.

Koskie is better defense at 3B than Rolen with better ROPS so likely to get more PA's than Rolen who gets the lefty platoon.

I'd take Renteria over Guillen at SS.

Kendall has better ROPS than Pudge.

Was this a serious question or were you just pointing out how strong this team is that they have guys that would start for most teams sitting on the farm team?