I agree 100%. One of the best players and SS to ever play the game gets a 1 rating? He's not even 30 years old. He'd be able to go back to SS and have the range and defensive ability he had last year. Make no sense to me. With that 1 rating, he will probably make an error a game. In real life, would ARod make that many errors at SS. No, so why the 1 rating?