Note: This section is now in read-only mode.
Please use our new community site for future posts.

Back To Board

Views on Rookies

Posted By Patrick

Hey Brian B.

Just a few additional comments on your Rookie list.

D. Wright - A solid ballplayer but watch out for a sophmore jinx (Eric Hinske comes to mind)!

B.J. Upton - Can get on base and has great speed. Can't play SS and doesn't have a position. Lots of upside but probably not in 2005.

J. Mauer - 2005 will tell if he can stay behind home plate with his knee.

S. Kazmir - Good prospect with questions about the number of walks and his control/arm strength.

Z. Greinke - Nice BB/K ratio and soild P prospect with a few too many dingers last year.

C. Kotchman - History of nagging injuries and can he turn those 2Bs into HRs. Probably will DH or split time with Erstad.

D. McPherson - Defense is iffy and lots of whiffs at AAA but has potential.

K. Matsui - 2005 should be much better indicator after making adjustment to MLB last season. I think he'll get better.

A. Rios - Maybe not in 2005 but probably soon after.

G. Sizemore - Good player and might get opportunity in CLV outfield.

D. Bush - Promising young pitcher.

J. Blanton - Has skills and will likely start in the rotation 2005. Can he live up to the hype?

J. Francis - Just say Coors Field and Pitcher over and over again on draft day.

J. Capellan - still pretty raw.

No one can break your heart faster than a promising young pitcher!