A few years back I had Troy Glaus with similar SS stats to A-Rods in a year Glaus hit 40+ HR. He outperformed A S Gonzalez at SS who was a fielding PB 8 or 9 that year - outperformed him by a lot.

I e-mailed the COMMISH showing my stats and suggesting the game should be changed so that guys with limited defensive stats are limited in their use at a position.

Also, I know KenG has A-Rod on at least one team and I think if you read his post above it suggests he may not be opposed to a change. I don't want to put words in his mouth though...