No
At least in all my experiences.
Certain guys just dont seem to perform.
while others overperform.
I have Alou now and 2 seasons in a row he has hit around .210 with minimal power.
I had Bagwell when he was a top hitter and he was terrible for seasons in a row.
it also happened to me when I had Randy Johnson.
He would put up the same numbers in MLB but would differ big time here.
One year unhitable the next totaly aweful.
But on the other side i had Erickson in his last full year he was an inn player with an era over 6.00 and he ended up putting up cy young numbers for me.
You just never know its a roll of the dice I say.